Jamie Holmes says a surgical procedure heart tried to make her pay for 2 operations after she underwent just one. She refused to buckle, even after a group company sued her final winter.
Holmes, who lives in northwestern Washington state, had surgical procedure in 2019 to have her fallopian tubes tied, a everlasting birth-control process that her insurance coverage firm agreed forward of time to cowl.
Through the operation, whereas Holmes was below anesthesia, the surgeon observed early indicators of endometriosis, a typical situation during which fibrous scar tissue grows across the uterus, Holmes mentioned. She mentioned the surgeon later instructed her he spent about quarter-hour cauterizing the troublesome tissue as a precaution. She recollects him saying he completed the entire operation inside the 60 minutes that had been allotted for the tubal ligation process alone.
She mentioned the physician assured her the additional remedy for endometriosis would value her little, if something.
Then the invoice got here.
The Affected person: Jamie Holmes, 38, of Lynden, Washington, who was insured by Premera Blue Cross on the time.
Medical Providers: A tubal ligation operation, plus remedy of endometriosis discovered through the surgical procedure.
Service Supplier: Pacific Rim Outpatient Surgical procedure Heart of Bellingham, Washington, which has since been bought, closed, and reopened below a brand new identify.
Complete Invoice: $9,620. Insurance coverage paid $1,262 to the in-network heart. After adjusting for costs allowed below the insurer’s contract, the middle billed Holmes $2,605. A group company later acquired the debt and sued her for $3,792.19, together with curiosity and costs.
What Provides: The surgical procedure heart, which supplied the ability and assist employees for her operation, despatched a invoice suggesting that Holmes underwent two separate operations, one to have her tubes tied and one to deal with endometriosis. It charged $4,810 for every.
Holmes mentioned there have been no such issues with the separate payments from the surgeon and anesthesiologist, which the insurer paid.
Holmes figured somebody within the heart’s billing division mistakenly thought she’d been on the working desk twice. She mentioned she tried to clarify it to the employees, to no avail.
She mentioned it was as if she ordered a meal at a fast-food restaurant, was given additional fries, after which was charged for 2 entire meals. “I didn’t get the additional burger and drink and a toy,” she joked.
Her insurer, Premera Blue Cross, declined to pay for 2 operations, she mentioned. The surgical procedure heart billed Holmes for a lot of the distinction. She refused to pay.
Holmes mentioned she understands the surgical procedure heart might have incurred extra prices for the roughly quarter-hour the surgeon spent cauterizing the spots of endometriosis. About $500 would have appeared like a good cost to her. “I’m not against paying for that,” she mentioned. “I’m against paying for an entire bunch of issues I didn’t obtain.”
The physician-owned surgical procedure heart was later bought and closed by PeaceHealth, a regional well being system. However the debt was turned over to a group company, SB&C, which filed go well with in opposition to Holmes in December 2023, looking for $3,792.19, together with curiosity and costs.
The gathering company requested a decide to grant abstract judgment, which might have allowed the corporate to garnish wages from Holmes’ job as a graphic artist and advertising specialist for actual property brokers.
Holmes mentioned she filed a written response, then confirmed up on Zoom and on the courthouse for 2 hearings, throughout which she defined her facet, with out bringing a lawyer. The decide dominated in February that the gathering company was not entitled to abstract judgment, as a result of the information of the case have been in dispute.
Representatives of the gathering company and the defunct surgical procedure heart declined to remark for this text.
Sabrina Corlette, co-director of Georgetown College’s Heart on Well being Insurance coverage Reforms, mentioned it was absurd for the surgical procedure heart to invoice for 2 operations after which refuse to again down when the scenario was defined. “It’s like a Kafka novel,” she mentioned.
Corlette mentioned surgical procedure heart staffers needs to be accustomed to such situations. “It’s fairly frequent, I might assume, for a surgeon to look inside anyone and say, ‘Oh, there’s this different factor occurring. I’m going to cope with it whereas I’ve obtained the affected person on the working desk.’”
It wouldn’t have made medical or monetary sense for the surgeon to make Holmes bear a separate operation for the secondary subject, she mentioned.
Corlette mentioned that if the surgical procedure heart was nonetheless in enterprise, she would advise the affected person to file a grievance with state regulators.
The Decision: Thus far, the gathering company has not pressed forward with its lawsuit by looking for a trial after the decide’s ruling. Holmes mentioned that if the company continues to sue her over the debt, she may rent a lawyer and sue them again, looking for damages and lawyer charges.
She might have organized to repay the quantity in installments. However she’s standing on precept, she mentioned.
“I simply obtained stonewalled so badly. They handled me like an fool,” she mentioned. “In the event that they’re going to be petty to me, I’m keen to be petty proper again.”
The Takeaway: Don’t be afraid to combat a bogus medical invoice, even when the dispute goes to courtroom.
Debt collectors usually search abstract judgment, which permits them to garnish wages or take different measures to grab cash with out going to the difficulty of proving in a trial that they’re entitled to funds. If the customers being sued don’t present as much as inform their facet in courtroom hearings, judges usually grant abstract judgment to the debt collectors.
Nonetheless, if the information of a case are in dispute — for instance, as a result of the defendant reveals up and argues she owes for only one surgical procedure, not two — the decide might deny abstract judgment and ship the case to trial. That forces the debt collector to decide on: spend extra money and time pursuing the debt or drop it.
“ what? It pays to be cussed in conditions like this,” mentioned Berneta Haynes, a senior lawyer for the Nationwide Client Regulation Heart who reviewed Holmes’ invoice for KFF Well being Information.
Many individuals don’t go to such hearings, typically as a result of they didn’t get sufficient discover, don’t learn English, or don’t have time, she mentioned.
“I believe lots of of us simply cave” after they’re sued, Haynes mentioned.
Emily Siner reported the audio story.
After six years, we’ll have a closing installment with NPR of our Invoice of the Month venture within the fall. However Invoice of the Month will proceed at KFF Health News and elsewhere. We nonetheless wish to hear about your complicated or outrageous medical payments. Go to Bill of the Month to share your story.
